• Insolvency Insider UK
  • Posts
  • ICG loses negligence claim against Colliers despite £4.75 million shopping centre overvaluation

ICG loses negligence claim against Colliers despite £4.75 million shopping centre overvaluation

High Court finds Colliers negligently valued a struggling retail property securing a £17.75 million loan, but rejects lender’s argument that an accurate valuation would have prompted an earlier sale and avoided subsequent losses

The High Court of England and Wales has dismissed a professional negligence claim brought by ICG Manager Limited and institutional investors against Colliers International Valuation UK LLP, despite finding that Colliers had negligently overvalued a shopping centre by £4.75 million. In a decision delivered on 13 November 2026, Mr David Halpern KC, sitting as a High Court judge, held that ICG failed to establish that it would have sold the property earlier had it received an accurate valuation, leaving the lender unable to recover damages despite proving negligence.

The dispute arose from a £17.75 million loan advanced in July 2015 to Runcorn One Ltd, secured against Shopping City, Halton Lea, a shopping centre in Cheshire. The loan was funded by investment vehicles associated with the BBC Pension Trust and BUPA Pension Scheme, with ICG acting as investment manager. Colliers initially valued the property at £28.44 million in 2015, a valuation that was not challenged. However, when ICG commissioned an updated valuation in January 2018, Colliers valued the property at £23.75 million, placing the loan-to-value ratio at 74.74%, just below the 75% threshold that would have entitled ICG to require the borrower to reduce its indebtedness.

The property's financial position subsequently deteriorated. In December 2018, Knight Frank informally advised ICG that the shopping centre was worth only £8.5 million to £9 million. ICG obtained another valuation from Colliers in January 2019, this time at £15.93 million, and subsequently appointed receivers from Savills in July 2019. After unsuccessful discussions with Halton Borough Council regarding a potential acquisition, the property was ultimately sold in October 2021 for £10.25 million.

ICG alleged that Colliers' January 2018 valuation had delayed enforcement action and exposed its investors to losses that could have been avoided through an earlier sale. Colliers argued that its duty did not extend to losses arising from commercial decisions about whether to retain or sell property securing an existing loan. The Court rejected that distinction, holding that a valuer's duty is, in principle, the same whether the valuation is obtained before a loan is advanced or during the life of an existing facility.

On negligence, the Court determined that the shopping centre's true value in January 2018 was £19 million, considerably below Colliers' £23.75 million assessment. It found that Colliers had placed excessive reliance on historic rental evidence in a declining market, failed to adequately account for tenant incentives and irrecoverable operating expenses, and overlooked significant weaknesses in the property. Applying a 15% permissible valuation margin, the Court concluded that the highest non-negligent valuation would have been £21.85 million.

However, establishing negligence was insufficient. ICG also had to demonstrate what it would have done had it received an accurate valuation. ICG maintained that it would have enforced the loan-to-value covenant, appointed receivers and sold the property by September 2018, before the market deteriorated further.

The Court was not persuaded. ICG's actual conduct after receiving Knight Frank's much lower valuation in December 2018 demonstrated a willingness to negotiate and explore alternatives rather than immediately realise its security. The Court also found that a hypothetical September 2018 sale would have required a distressed-sale discount of approximately 20%, producing proceeds of approximately £11.36 million, substantially below the outstanding loan. It was therefore not satisfied that ICG would have proceeded with such a sale.

The claim was dismissed.

William Flenley KC and Alicia Tew, both of Hailsham Chambers (instructed by Burges Salmon) acted for ICG et al., while Patrick Lawrence KC and Scott Allen (instructed by RPC) acted for Colliers.