• Insolvency Insider UK
  • Posts
  • Irish court rules liquidators may have to repay fees to cover adverse litigation costs

Irish court rules liquidators may have to repay fees to cover adverse litigation costs

High Court rejects €384,000 security for costs application against Blackbee Investments, finding that adverse costs orders rank ahead of liquidators’ remuneration and previously paid fees may have to be returned if the liquidation cannot satisfy them

The Irish High Court has rejected an application by Inua Hospitality plc for approximately €384,000 in security for costs in litigation brought against it by Blackbee Investments Limited (in liquidation), ruling that liquidators who unsuccessfully pursue litigation on behalf of an insolvent company may be required to repay their own remuneration to ensure that a successful defendant's legal costs are paid. In a judgment delivered on 12 November 2026, Justice Twomey held that adverse costs orders arising from litigation commenced by a company in liquidation rank ahead of the liquidators' remuneration, and that previously paid fees may have to be returned if insufficient funds remain to satisfy the order.

Blackbee was wound up by order of the High Court on 19 May 2023, with Luke Charleton and Alan Large of EY Ireland appointed joint liquidators. In August 2025, Blackbee commenced proceedings against Inua seeking to recover money allegedly owed in connection with fundraising undertaken on Inua's behalf. Inua subsequently applied for security for costs under section 52 of the Companies Act 2014, arguing that Blackbee might be unable to pay its estimated defence costs of €383,920, excluding VAT, if the litigation failed.

According to evidence provided by the liquidators, Blackbee held approximately €417,453 in cash as of 14 July 2026, had realised approximately €2.19 million in assets and anticipated further recoveries of €1.73 million before the end of 2026. The liquidators had also received €362,589 in remuneration. Inua argued that the existing cash balance provided only an 8% cushion over its estimated costs and questioned whether an eventual costs award would rank ahead of other liquidation expenses.

The central dispute concerned section 617 of the Companies Act 2014, which establishes priorities for expenses incurred in winding up a company. Inua argued that because the provision does not expressly identify adverse litigation costs as a priority expense, a successful defendant could not assume that its costs would rank ahead of the expenses of administering the liquidation. Blackbee disputed that interpretation, relying on earlier Irish authorities recognising the priority of adverse costs orders arising from litigation pursued after liquidation.

Justice Twomey found it unnecessary to resolve the broader statutory interpretation dispute. Instead, he relied on the Irish Supreme Court's decision in Eteams International (In Liquidation) v The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland [2020] IESC 23, which confirmed that costs awarded against a company in litigation pursued by its liquidator are expenses of the winding up and rank ahead of the liquidator's remuneration.

The Court emphasised the underlying policy rationale: defendants should not be forced to bear the costs of successfully defending claims brought by liquidators for the benefit of an insolvent estate. This priority also creates a direct financial incentive for liquidators to exercise care when pursuing litigation, since their remuneration is subordinated to an adverse costs award and may have to be repaid if the estate cannot satisfy it.

In Blackbee's case, Large had sworn that sufficient funds would be available to meet any adverse costs order and confirmed that professional fees already paid remained subject to reconciliation at the conclusion of the liquidation. Justice Twomey observed that the €362,589 previously paid to the liquidators represented a substantial potential source of recovery against Inua's estimated costs of €383,920, even before considering Blackbee's existing cash and anticipated asset realisations.

The Court also attached weight to the liquidators' status as officers of the court, their professional standing at EY Ireland and their solicitors' written assurance that sufficient funds would be retained within the liquidation to satisfy an adverse costs order.

Justice Twomey concluded that Inua had failed to establish a reason to believe Blackbee would be unable to pay an adverse costs award, rejecting its application for security for costs.